Local elections show that South Africa’s women continue to play second fiddle
- Lisa Vetten
The recent municipal elections do not show that political parties consider women’s issues relevant or important.
Three events converge in August in South Africa: the 60th anniversary of the to the ; the finalisation of the local government ; and the tenth anniversary of the trial of President Jacob Zuma for . They act as a prism, refracting South Africa鈥檚 politics of gender, its uneven legacies and its ambiguous futures.
Sixty years after women marched on Pretoria and 22 years after the first there are no visible champions of women鈥檚 rights. In fact, the gains that have been made risk being rolled back.
Progress from 1956 to democracy
The first moment of women鈥檚 mass political mobilisation as women was through the Federation of South 第一吃瓜网 Women (Fedsaw), inaugurated in 1954 with the adoption of the . Fedsaw organised its first national protest against the extension of the hated 鈥 identity documents used to control the movement of black people during apartheid 鈥 to black women in 1955. But it is the protest march of August 9 1956 for which they are justly honoured.
Political repression led to Fedsaw鈥檚 dissipation in the early 1960s, but its memory inspired the 1994 . This was the fruit of the 鈥 the second moment of South 第一吃瓜网 women鈥檚 widespread mobilisation, made possible by the transition to democracy.
This moment yielded important gains. Some of these included:
-
marked increases in women鈥檚 representation in parliament;
-
the entrenchment of gender equality in the final of democratic South Africa;
-
the establishment of the national gender machinery. This consisted of the Office on the Status of Women (housed in the Presidency), the Joint Monitoring Committee on the Improvement of the Quality of Life and Status of Women in parliament, and the Commission for Gender Equality, an independent ; and
-
the enactment of important legislation such as the , the and the .
These measures advanced women鈥檚 status in important ways. They also attempted to improve the position of black women, and those living under customary law in particular.
The women鈥檚 vote
The 2015 South 第一吃瓜网 showed women were less satisfied with the country鈥檚 . Whether these attitudes influenced local government election outcomes is a matter of speculation. No data are available providing a gender-disaggregated breakdown either of registered voters, or those who actually voted.
Through their choice of political representatives, or the content of their manifestos, political parties certainly did not give the impression that there was a 鈥渨omen鈥檚 vote鈥 to influence.
Half of all municipal councils鈥 seats in local government elections are ward councillor seats. The remaining seats are calculated proportional to the party鈥檚 representation.
Sixty percent of the governing 第一吃瓜网 National Congress (ANC) and opposition Economic Freedom Fighters鈥 (EFF) proportional representation candidates were . The main opposition Democratic Alliance (DA) fielded only one-third women. Only one-third of ward councillors proposed by all three parties were .
It is argued that including more women in policymaking processes will better promote women鈥檚 rights and interests. But whether this goal can be accomplished depends significantly on the extent to which gender is substantively embedded in parties鈥 manifestos.
Neither the DA nor the EFF made specific reference to women and gender equality in their . The ANC for its part proposed no more than what was already in place. This is prioritising women鈥檚 inclusion within the Expanded Public Works Programme and consultation with stakeholders around the problem of violence against women.
Jacob Zuma鈥檚 rape trial
Gender featured only weakly in the recent elections. It took the silent protest, , at the Independent Electoral Commission to dramatically reinsert these questions of women鈥檚 absence into the heart of our politics.
In 2005 鈥淜hwezi鈥, whose father had been a close friend of Zuma鈥檚 in exile, accused Zuma of rape. When the trial began in 2006 it shattered the idea that women share the same agenda, priorities or interests. The trial pitted largely urban, feminist women鈥檚 rights activists against largely rural, . It also saw the ANC Women鈥檚 League remain silent on the threats against Khwezi, and the phallic, aggressive masculinity the .
Precisely how this masculinity was to be understood, and what its place was within the politics of the ANC, was a central feature of the later controversy surrounding Brett Murray鈥檚 painting, 鈥溾. These questions surfaced yet again when ANC politician Marius Fransman, accused of sexually assaulting Louisa Wynand earlier , electioneered alongside Zuma.
The ANC鈥檚 once undeniable commitment to gender equality is now a withered imitation of its former self. Yet the DA and EFF provide little in the way of an alternative.
The DA鈥檚 particular brand of liberalism has proved impervious to feminist ideals. In addition, the marriage between feminism and socialism 鈥 including the EFF鈥檚 version of choice, Marxist-Leninism 鈥 has never been a happy one. A strong commitment to practising gender equality seems unlikely in this context.
However, the EFF demonstrates commitment to women鈥檚 representation. Yet female EFF leaders, who are powerful and articulate individuals in their own right, play second fiddle to the party鈥檚 male national leadership. The DA does not support gender quotas but has produced (originally of the Pan 第一吃瓜网ist Congress and the Independent Democrats), , and .
There are lessons to reflect on in South Africa鈥檚 . The country鈥檚 past tells us that, under certain conditions, women mobilise in ways that produce significant political results. Our present shows how easily these gains can evaporate. And our future urges us to look within the unfamiliar political spaces created by the contradictions of the present to forge new practices of gender equality.
, Honorary Research Associate, Wits Institute for Social and Economic Research, . This article was originally published on . Read the .