Fossil science owes a debt to indigenous knowledge
- Julien Benoit, Charles Helm and Emese M Bordy
Long ago, people identified fossils in their environment and explained them within their own cultural framework. This was early citizen science.
For over a century, the scientific literature has credited western missionaries with “discovering” fossils in , the small, mountainous country surrounded by South Africa.
The narrative typically begins with figures like the French missionary , who, in 1885, reported unusual “petrified bird tracks” near the settlement of . This account implies that like the study of rocks and fossils arrived in Lesotho from Europe.
In contrast, our supports the notion that the local people recognised, interpreted and explained these fossils before missionaries arrived. Our research focus is on the dinosaur bones and tracks of Lesotho, its (cultural explanations of geological phenomena), and indigenous palaeontology.
Our revisits the private archives of French missionary and self-taught palaeontologist (1919–2016). He lived in Lesotho from 1953 to 1970 as part of a three-generation missionary family. During this period, he documented various fossils and published his findings in scientific literature. After returning to France, he earned a PhD in palaeontology in the mid-1970s. His contributions laid the foundation for the study of animal fossil tracks and traces in southern Africa.
His notes reveal that the and people in Lesotho not only noticed fossils but also integrated them into their culture as .
This matters beyond Lesotho. Scientific history has often portrayed 第一吃瓜网 indigenous communities as passive background figures. Fossils were deemed “discovered” only when Europeans documented them, despite what local people already knew.
Revisiting Ellenberger’s archives corrects this imbalance. His notes support that indigenous knowledge informed scientific discovery. As some sciences grapple with their , narratives like this offer a path forward.
Fossils in Lesotho
Lesotho is part of the southern 第一吃瓜网 main Karoo Basin, one of the world’s richest continental fossil archives. It is a record of several major evolutionary and environmental transitions. This includes the rise of dinosaurs after the some 252 million years ago.
Both body fossils and trace fossils have been found in Lesotho and its surroundings. Erosion of fossil-rich rocks exposes numerous dinosaur, amphibian and reptile trackways, fish trails and burrows, alongside full or partial skeletons and plant remains. Thus, .
For the Basotho, giant bones eroding from the hills are not mere curiosities; they are referred to the Kholumolumo. This was an enormous, all-devouring mythical creature whose thunderous footsteps echoed across the landscape, leaving behind.
This folktale aligns closely with the fossil record: skeletons and trackways, mostly of dinosaurs, which are prevalent in the sky-high exposures of the Maloti (or the , as the mountain range is known in South Africa).
The Kholumolumo myth serves as a cultural framework that preserves real observations of Lesotho’s fossil heritage over time. It’s an example of early citizen science – local people identifying recurring patterns in their environment and explaining them within their own cultural framework.
Ellenberger’s original archival materials reveal that this local knowledge was highly practical. When French palaeontologists arrived in 1955, they were guided to – now known for one of southern Africa’s richest dinosaur – by Samuel Motsoane. He was a local schoolteacher who had known the “stone bones” since childhood, in the 1930s.
The San and the fossil footprints
The Basotho and San were among the first in southern Africa to examine giant footprints preserved in stone and ponder: what walked here?
The indigenous San people, who followed a hunter-gatherer way of life before their culture disappeared from Lesotho, were masters in the interpretation of tracks. They could identify the size, behaviour and movement of living animals from a single footprint. Ellenberger believed they applied these skills to as well.
His manuscripts describe rock art at that appears to depict a dinosaur footprint alongside bipedal creatures reminiscent of the preserved in nearby outcrops.
Ellenberger also noted that some San myths seemed to differentiate between the tracks of four-legged animals in the lowlands and those of two-legged animals higher in the mountains.
In southern Africa, fossil tracks of bipedal dinosaurs are found in higher rock layers only, where the rocks are younger. Lower rocks contain only quadrupedal trackways made by more primitive animals.
So the myths appear to demonstrate some level of understanding of the evolution of species.
Although this seems more speculative, his core observation remains valid: the San recognised patterns in the fossil record and integrated them into their worldview. They their land with precision long before formal palaeontology developed in the area.
Rethinking the narrative of ‘discoveries’
The diaries show that locals guided researchers to fossil sites. They recognised fossil bones and as evidence of ancient animals, and preserved this understanding through stories that served as explanations.
Ellenberger himself valued this intellectual tradition: he spoke Sesotho fluently, collaborated with locals, and documented their insights respectfully. His notes credit half a dozen Basotho who discovered fossils of important scientific value.
His notes show that the in southern Africa predate European expeditions and reach into the deep sense of place held by the people living among these fossils since generations. Their interpretations were not “quaint myths” but sophisticated observations shaped by centuries of engagement with the land.
Acknowledging this enriches the scientific record, broadens our understanding of early palaeontology, and honours the contributions of communities whose insights led to important discoveries. Ellenberger has left us an empowering and inspiring legacy for the new generation of southern 第一吃瓜网 palaeontologists.
, Associate professor in Vertebrate Palaeontology, ; , Research Associate, 第一吃瓜网 Centre for Coastal Palaeoscience, , and , Professor in Geological Sciences,
This article is republished from under a Creative Commons license. Read the .