Reflections on South Africa鈥檚 Medium Term Budget Policy Statement (MTBPS)
By Dr Kenneth Creamer, School of Economics and Finance, University of the Witwatersrand, October 2026
The was delivered in a global context with conflict, inflation, and public finances under strain with bond market turmoil. In contrast, the MTBPS has a message of optimism, stability, and increased buffers against shocks. We specifically heard about funds earmarked for drought and El Nino relief.
Kenneth Creamer: There are always trade-offs in any budget. Yes, last week’s budget statement was able to generate optimism about containing and reducing South Africa’s national debt which had been rising sharply over the past decade, this is a good thing and it must be done as it will mean that in future fewer public resources will be required to pay debt service costs. But as we know, the fiscal discipline required to run a primary surplus and contain debt means that in the immediate term there are fewer public resources for service delivery and public spending. I think we have got the balance right, but the trade-off will become more difficult if global conditions continue to deteriorate and will become easier if electricity, rail and other restructuring programmes continue to lift domestic growth and investment.
On preparing for El Nino. It is a reality of budgeting in the context of climate change that planning must take into account the probability of increased occurrences of droughts, floods, changing agricultural and disease patterns. South Africa’s geography incorporates different climatic zones which may be impacted differently at different times. It is prudent that we begin to plan in our budget to respond to these realities.
Question 1: The Finance Minister emphasised fiscal stability, credibility, and sustainability. We received the announcement of the fiscal anchor legislation being released for public comment – where fiscal sustainability will now have some legislative guardrails.
Kenneth Creamer: In macroeconomic policy thinking there have been long and intense debates about guiding frameworks for monetary and fiscal policy. Monetary policy has currently settled on inflation targeting to support growth, instead of exchange rate targeting, or money supply targeting, for example. To anchor fiscal policy there are also has a variety of frameworks available including setting deficit limits (such as in the Maastricht Treaty), or following a golden rule, where borrowing can only be used by governments for capital investments, not consumption. In many instances, fiscal frameworks have been less successful than on the monetary side, as shocks and political pressures have made adherence difficult and as a result many countries have breached their own fiscal rules. Against this background I think South Africa is suitably cautious and seeks to firmly commit future fiscal policy to be avoid rising debt, while at the same time allowing some flexibility. If done correctly this will in my view add to the credibility of South Africa’s fiscal approach over time as it will mandate decision makers to actively avoid rising national debt without setting up the kind of obvious trip wires that have destroyed fiscal credibility in the experiences of a number of other countries.
Question 2: Another core theme of the was investment and infrastructure – described as a catalyst for growth and the Finance Minister underscoring the impact it has on people’s daily lives, whether through electricity or water supply.
Kenneth Creamer: Yes, investment in South Africa is currently at around 15% of GDP, whereas a more inclusive growth path would require that investment should rise to 25% of GDP. To lift investment requires three major drivers – private sector investment, investment by major state-owned companies and capital investment linked to government services. All three of these components have been heading in the wrong direction, but signs are that we may be at a turning point. Firstly, government investment has been crowded out by driving debt service costs, as well as corruption and incapacity – by containing debt and debt service costs the objective is to uplift general government investment levels – as the Minister implied Rands used directly for service delivery work harder for the people than Rands used to pay historical debts. Also, the Budget Facility for Infrastructure is aimed at improving state capacity to design and implement capital projects. Secondly, major supply-side restructuring is underway in sectors such as electricity and logistics to create a better eco-system to promote investment by state owned companies and the private sector. One of the main objectives of creating a competitive electricity market – to be launched in April 2027 – is to stimulate increased levels for investment in the electricity sector with the objective of strengthening security of supply and containing the future electricity price pathway. Similarly, investment into building 14 000km national grid is to be driven by the NTCSA – with a component of electricity tariffs to be dedicated to the funding of transmission infrastructure – together with private sector investment in grid projects through Build Operate and Transfer mechanisms facilitated by the credit guarantee vehicle. Also in the logistics sector, for the first time in South Africa, frameworks have been put into placed to facilitate a combination of public and private investment in rail and ports services. All of these factors together represent a strong effort to lift investment levels in South Africa – this area must be closely watched as the issues are complex and require skill, high levels of coordination and the careful management of vested interests if we are to be successful.
Question 3: Before we open up to questions from the audience – and members of the business community – greater fiscal discipline and investment should help support the enabling conditions for the private sector, to what extent do we think businesses has welcomed announcements in the ?
Kenneth Creamer: There has been a trust deficit in South Africa which still needs to be overcome. Due to our apartheid history, as well as the more recent history of state capture, it is hard for South 第一吃瓜网s to cohere around our national economic interests (as we do sometimes around sporting achievements) as we don’t really trust that the other person is committed to the project of nation building. The messages in the budget statement make sense and provide clear signals as to what should be done, but until we find a way to trust each other – I think distrust will continue to be another constraint that we will have to learn to overcome.
